Software comparison

Vendor management software for facilities: a side-by-side comparison

Five tools compete directly with Evalystar for facilities and procurement teams: VendorPM, ServiceChannel, Fexa, Corrigo (JLL) and Gatekeeper. Evalystar checks whether a vendor is already under contract at the moment a job is booked, and of the six it is the only one with free public rate benchmarks (8 trades, 24 cities) and a permanent free plan. CMMS tools like UpKeep and MaintainX are not on that list: they run work orders, and Evalystar sits beside them.

By Thomas Renon, CEO & co-founder. Updated October 4, 2026.

Start free See pricing

HVACNorthline Mechanical

All-time performance

Avg rating4.6

Total jobs118

Total reviews87

Summary

The direct competitors to Evalystar are VendorPM, ServiceChannel, Fexa, Corrigo (JLL) and Gatekeeper, because they serve the same facilities and procurement buyer for the same vendor decisions.
Evalystar checks whether a vendor is already under contract before a job is booked; the other five hold contracts, but public information shows that check only partly tied to booking, or not at all.
Evalystar, ServiceChannel, Fexa and Corrigo check vendor invoices; Evalystar compares each invoice against the contract and the jobs recorded, and does not raise purchase orders or pay invoices.
Evalystar publishes free rate benchmarks by trade and city; ServiceChannel offers benchmarking to its customers only.
CMMS platforms such as UpKeep, MaintainX and Maintenance Care run work orders for internal teams and are not Evalystar competitors; Evalystar is not a CMMS.
Evalystar has a permanent free plan with unlimited sites, users and vendors; every direct competitor on this page uses custom pricing.

What Evalystar is not

"Vendor management" covers several unrelated software categories, and most shortlists go wrong by mixing them. Evalystar sits in one of them and not the others:

Gets you quotes from vendors already in your pool, ranked by their real performance history; checks vendor invoices against the contract and the work recorded, but is not a source-to-pay or procurement suite that raises purchase orders or approves and pays invoices (Coupa, SAP Ariba, Jaggaer, Ivalua, GEP SMART).
Not a contingent workforce vendor management system for staffing contractors (SAP Fieldglass, Beeline).
Not a third-party risk or compliance platform (Vanta, Venminder).
Not a CMMS or work order system (UpKeep, MaintainX, Maintenance Care), and not field service software for contractors (ServiceTitan, Jobber).
Evalystar's vendor records are built from real performance data on completed field-service work, not spend or status alone.

What to look for

Which questions should the software answer?

Ratings alone are not enough to choose a tool: any work-order system can add a rating form. The questions that separate these products are the ones procurement asks before money moves. Is this job already covered by a contract we pay for? Does the invoice match the contract and the work that was done? Is the price fair for this trade in this city? And, after the job, did the vendor actually perform?

At a glance

How do the direct competitors compare?

Capability	Evalystar	VendorPM	ServiceChannel	Fexa	Corrigo (JLL)	Gatekeeper
Contract check before a job is booked	Yes	Contract repository	Partial	Partial	Partial	Repository, not tied to jobs
Invoice check against contract and work done	Yes	Not found	Yes	Yes, core	Yes	No
Public rate benchmarks by trade and city	Yes, free	Not found	Customers only	Not found	Not found	No
Quote requests and vendor sourcing	Yes, from your pool	Yes, marketplace	Yes, provider network	Not found	Yes, provider network	Not found
Job-level ratings by site staff	Yes, multi-rater	Limited	Yes, scorecards	Quarterly reviews	Not found	Scorecards, not job-level
COI and compliance	Limited	Yes, core	Yes	Not found	Yes	Yes
Work orders and preventive maintenance	No, by design	No	Yes, core	Yes, core	Yes, core	No
Contract lifecycle and renewals	Yes, AI renewal insights	Yes	Partial	Partial	Partial	Yes, core
Free plan and public pricing	Yes	No	No	No	No	No

Competitor details come from each vendor's public website and third-party listings as of October 2026. "Not found" means we could not confirm the capability publicly, not that it does not exist. If something here is out of date, tell us and we will correct it.

Direct competitors

Same buyer, same job

These tools are bought by the same facilities and procurement teams to manage the same vendors. Choosing between them and Evalystar is a genuine either-or decision.

Evalystar

Facility and procurement teams, small to mid-market multi-siteThis is us

Vendor management software that checks whether a vendor is already under contract before a job is booked, ranks your own pool by job ratings, sends quote requests, has site staff rate every completed job in a few taps, and checks invoices against the contract and the work done. Free public rate benchmarks for 8 trades in 24 cities. Permanent free plan; Pro is priced per site. Not a work-order system.

VendorPM

Property managers sourcing new vendors

Canadian vendor credentialing and e-bidding marketplace with AI contract management, renewals and a vendor portal. Claims 100,000+ vendors, 150+ property management firms and 15,000+ buildings. Strongest on network scale and compliance; vendors pay to be listed. Custom pricing.

Evalystar vs VendorPM →

ServiceChannel

Enterprise multi-site retail, restaurants, grocery

Facilities work-order platform (Fortive) with a provider network, scorecards, invoice compliance and benchmarking for its customers. Covers most of the same ground at enterprise grade, with a heavy implementation. Providers pay 1.5% per approved invoice, capped at $4.

Evalystar vs ServiceChannel →

Fexa

Enterprise multi-location retail and manufacturing

Multi-site FM work orders and vendor operations, with invoice compliance rules per vendor trade and asset class and quarterly vendor reviews. Claims 20 to 30% less invoice processing time. Custom pricing.

Evalystar vs Fexa →

Corrigo (JLL)

Large CRE owners and JLL-managed portfolios

CRE and FM work orders with a service-provider network (CorrigoPro) and built-in invoicing, owned by JLL alongside Building Engines. Strong distribution through JLL. Custom pricing.

Evalystar vs Corrigo →

Gatekeeper

Procurement, legal and finance

Vendor and contract lifecycle management: contract repository, workflows, custom scorecards, renewal alerts and AI clause extraction across every supplier category. Manages the contract; does not record the work done under it. Priced by number of third parties.

Evalystar vs Gatekeeper →

Vertical incumbents

Systems that already own the workflow in one industry

Customers in these industries already log their jobs here. Evalystar either sits beside them or sells to a different buyer in the same organisation.

FMX and Brightly (SchoolDude)

K-12 and higher education

The default facilities systems in school districts. Vendor management is not their focus, so vendor ratings and contract checks sit alongside them rather than against them.

TELS (Direct Supply)

Senior living and long-term care

Building-services platform from the dominant supplier to senior living, with its own vendor network and vendor-management insights.

Angus AnyWare (MRI Software)

Canadian commercial landlords

Building operations software for Canadian commercial real estate, distributed through MRI Software.

Property Meld, Vendoroo, Yardi, RealPage

Residential property management

Maintenance coordination and procure-to-pay tools for residential portfolios. Vendoroo routes jobs to the "best" vendor with AI. Residential is outside Evalystar's focus.

Compliance and prequalification

When the question is insurance and safety

If your main need is certificates of insurance and contractor prequalification, these tools go deeper than Evalystar does today.

NetVendor

Property management compliance

Credentialed vendor network with COI enforcement, renewals and bidding.

Avetta

Enterprise contractor safety

Two-sided contractor compliance network covering safety and ESG prequalification.

Highwire

Owner-side contractor safety scores

Gives owners a safety and performance score for each contractor.

Jones

COI tracking in commercial real estate

AI certificate-of-insurance tracking for commercial real estate.

Not competitors

Tools Evalystar sits beside

These come up in the same searches but do a different job. A CMMS holds the work orders; contractor software is what your vendors run. Evalystar is neither.

UpKeep

Internal maintenance teams (CMMS)

Mobile-first CMMS for work orders, assets and technician dispatch. Holds the work orders; does not check vendor contracts, rate vendor jobs or check vendor invoices.

Evalystar vs UpKeep →

MaintainX

Internal maintenance teams (CMMS)

CMMS and operations platform for in-house maintenance staff: work orders, procedures and asset tracking.

Evalystar vs MaintainX →

Maintenance Care

Internal maintenance teams (CMMS)

CMMS with an Always Free tier for basic work orders and paid tiers for preventive maintenance and assets. Others in the same category include Limble, Fiix, eMaint, Hippo and IBM Maximo.

Evalystar vs Maintenance Care →

ServiceTitan

Trades businesses (contractor-side)

Field service software the contractor uses to run scheduling, dispatch and invoicing. Your vendors may run it; the client hiring them would not. Jobber sits in the same category.

Evalystar vs ServiceTitan →

Decision guide

How do you choose?

If you needStop paying for work a contract already covers, check invoices, and rate every vendor job, without replacing your work-order system

ConsiderEvalystar

If you needFind and credential vendors you have never worked with, with COI tracking

ConsiderVendorPM

If you needOne enterprise platform for work orders, a provider network and invoice compliance across hundreds of locations

ConsiderServiceChannel, Fexa or Corrigo

If you needContract lifecycle and clause management across every supplier category

ConsiderGatekeeper

If you needWork orders and preventive maintenance for an internal team

ConsiderA CMMS such as UpKeep or MaintainX, with Evalystar beside it for outside vendors

FAQ

Common questions.

A CMMS such as UpKeep or MaintainX schedules and closes work orders for your own maintenance team. Vendor management software for facilities, like Evalystar, manages the outside vendors you pay: whether a job is already covered by a contract, how each vendor performed, and whether the invoice matches. Many teams run both.

The tools that serve the same buyer for the same job are VendorPM, ServiceChannel, Fexa, Corrigo (JLL) and Gatekeeper. CMMS platforms like UpKeep and MaintainX are not direct competitors: they hold the work orders, and Evalystar sits beside them.

Among the tools on this page, ServiceChannel, Fexa, Corrigo and Evalystar check vendor invoices. Evalystar compares each invoice against the contract and the jobs recorded for that vendor; it does not raise purchase orders or pay invoices. We found no invoice reconciliation in VendorPM or Gatekeeper.

It depends on the tool. In Evalystar vendors never log in or pay; your team rates the work. ServiceChannel charges providers a fee on approved invoices, and VendorPM vendors pay to be listed on its marketplace.

Not Evalystar, and it is not meant to. Evalystar does not run work orders or preventive maintenance. ServiceChannel, Fexa and Corrigo do include work orders, which is why adopting them usually means replacing the system you have.

Talk to the team

Try Evalystar free.

No credit card. No sales call. Up and running in 20 minutes.

A real person reads every message
Demo requests get a tailored walkthrough
Or skip the call: the Free plan needs no card

Start free instead